Montana Families Pay Less to Live Near Good Schools Than Most of the Country, Study Shows

When my husband and I started looking at buying a house, school boundaries never came up in the conversation the way they do for a lot of families. We homeschool our son, so a district line on a map has never been what stood between us and a house we liked. But I know that's not the reality for most parents, and a new study puts real numbers behind just how much that reality costs.

A study from K12 compared home values against school achievement data in all 50 states, and it turns out Montana families face less of that pressure than most of the country, even if the tradeoff still shows up somewhere.

Montana Homes Near Top Schools Cost About $117,000 More

Nationwide, homes in top-rated school areas cost roughly 1.7 times as much as homes in the lowest-rated areas, a gap of about $175,000.

In Montana, that gap is smaller. Homes near the state's top-rated schools cost about 1.32 times as much as homes near the lowest-rated ones, a difference of roughly $117,022. That puts Montana among the states with the smallest school-district housing premiums in the country, well below places like California, where the same gap runs nearly $900,000.

Families Nationwide Are Moving, Cutting Vacations and Taking Second Jobs

The relief in those Montana numbers doesn't mean the pressure disappears everywhere else. Researchers surveyed 660 parents across the country and found 63 percent had either moved or seriously considered moving for a better public school district. Of families who went through with a move, 94 percent said they made at least one financial sacrifice to make it work.

The most common sacrifice was taking on a higher mortgage or rent, reported by 46 percent of families who moved. Others cut vacations or other spending, delayed a major purchase, accepted a longer commute, or took a second job to cover the cost.

Even a Smaller Gap Still Shapes Family Budgets

Nationally, researchers found that in 37 of the 50 states, financing the extra cost of a home in a top-rated school district over a 30-year mortgage would run families more per year than average private school tuition. Montana's smaller premium likely softens that math somewhat, but a $117,000 difference in home price still means a real difference in a monthly payment over three decades.

That's the part of these studies that doesn't always make it into the numbers. A smaller gap compared to New York or New Jersey is still a gap. It still means some families are choosing a smaller house, a longer commute, or a delayed project so their kids land in a certain district.

A Question That Follows Families Long After the Move

What stuck with me most in the survey results wasn't the dollar figures. It was that 82 percent of parents said a child's education shouldn't be determined by where a family can afford to live, while 92 percent believe wealthier families end up with better school options anyway. Those two numbers sitting next to each other say something most parents already know without needing a study to tell them.

Get our free mobile app

We opted out of that particular calculation by homeschooling, but I know plenty of families in this town who didn't have that option and had to make a harder call between a house they could afford and a school they wanted. This study puts a number on a decision many Montana parents are already making quietly, one mortgage payment at a time.